I’m sure it happens to everybody.  I know, self-assuringly, that I’m not alone on this…  I’m sure that once in a while, we all come across a recipe, a “trick” really, that gets us so excited we forget to reasonably doubt and then it fails on such an epic proportion that we quiver at the sight of the kitchen doorway for a week.  Say it is so.

Well… even so, two days ago, when my cold lingered on and my eyes were so dry from the medication that they were about to crack open, it just wasn’t… really wasn’t the best time for this to happen.

And yet it so did.  Three times it did.

brown-butter-hollandaise brown-butter-hollandaise3brown-butter-hollandaise5

I love brunch.  I love brunch because the imagery of social vibrancy it paints, sun-dresses… side-walk seating… lively conversations, but no less than any of that, I love brunch because there will be hollandaise sauce.  A sauce that isn’t really a “sauce”, but a mayonnaise-equivalent in disguise that somehow feels more OK to be poured over my eggs… I dig that.  But strangely, for someone who isn’t unfamiliar with emulsified sauces, this and that, I’ve never attempted to make hollandaise.  Perhaps because the thought of a “double boiler” ignites the need for a nap and not motivation.  So the night before the incidence when I came across a, quote-unquote “Kick Ass Hollandaise” recipe using a blender, with the signature of Eric Ripert stamped on it, I was sold.  The idea of heating butter and let the hot, melted butter slowly cook and thicken the egg yolks in the blender, sounded logical enough, and I ushered it into production the next day.

I melted the butter, browned it even to nutty goodness.  I thought, I got this.  I thought it was going to come together beautifully like all my butter sauces had.  It didn’t.  It broke, irreversibly, along with my most sentimental heart.


What… the fuck?  I stood there staring at the fluid-splattered crime scene and was stunned by the coagulating presence for a frozen three minutes.  The blunt and unconcealed puddle of failure struck my core.  Me…!  Me who once, on her first try without prior experience, made bearnaise sauce on the stove, over DIRECT heat.  DIRECT HEAT!  Me, who once stared into the face of mocking Provençals with defiance (mentally at least) and made perfectly creamy aioli in nothing but a stone mortar.  STONE MORTAR!  I was so sure… I got this.  There are people who once said that butter sauces smell fear…  But no.  No they don’t.  They smell audacity… arrogance… one slight loss of modesty and it will break itself, and you with it, in the most tragic liquid death you can pour into a weeping sink…

To add to my tragedy and your entertainment, I regrouped to try again.  Twice more.  And still no hollandaise sauce…  I’ve never butchered so much butter within such a short time-frame with nothing to eat at the end of it… it felt like the filth of guilt.  I later forced myself back into the kitchen to make dinner… just to punish myself!  It didn’t taste like redemption either.

brown-butter-hollandaise9 brown-butter-hollandaise11

The rest of the day, I spent it in a fetal position sucking my thumb, mentally examining my failure CSI-style.  I first blamed Eric.  What a fucking liar.  This is why recipes have to be long, explicitly, in details!  Kick-ass hollandaise?  Yeah, the only ass it kicked was my ass.  And blender?!  BLENDER?!!  Maybe he forgot to ask “Are you making hollandaise for 20 people like in my fabulous restaurant?”, well then, NO, NO I wasn’t!  Because he should’ve mentioned what a blender does if you feed it with only a VERY SMALL amount of liquid.  It SPLATTERS!  The spinning blade splashes the egg yolks so violently everywhere in 360º, the mixture was more likely to end up on the ceiling than the bottom of the blender to duly emulsify with the added butter.

Seriously… Eric.

If there’s one piece of machine to help us pull this off, this being the nuttiest and most intense BROWNED/BURNT BUTTER HOLLANDAISE you’ll ever taste, it shouldn’t be a fucking blender.  It should be, a stand-mixer!  A piece of equipment that provides high friction but at the same time, keeping it relatively in one place.  A piece of equipment that doesn’t only do the sauce, but also inherently KEEPING it inside a heat-proof bowl that will stay warm, without any left-behind sauce that goes to waste (hello~ blender?!).  A piece of equipment that gave me the most glorious and delicious redemption the next day, one try, and saved my will to ever cook again.

I tell you it is so.

brown-butter-hollandaise14 brown-butter-hollandaise16

Serves: brunch-portion hollandaise for max 4 people

Unlike many recipes that suggest mixing unmelted, cubed butter into the egg yolks over gentle heat which I admit is easier and more “foolproof”, this sauce requires using butter that’s browned/borderline-burnt and therefore in liquid form.  The risk is higher but it gives an ENTIRELY different dimension of flavour and aroma to the hollandaise that I promise, is worth the trouble.  But since all the moisture in the butter that’s crucial for establishing an emulsification, has all evaporated during the browning, we need to re-introduce it back into the recipe, and that is where the whole milk comes in.   Keep more than 1 tbsp of hot whole milk on the side for fixing a broken heart hollandaise sauce if it happens (Apparently Downton Abbey says “It’s easier to fix a hollandaise sauce than a broken heart”…. as later I was told by Google.  Great.  Just great).

UPDATED 2016/11/01: Changed 1 tbsp of milk to 2 tbsp.  Works better.


  • 3 large egg yolks
  • 1/2 tsp of salt
  • 1/4 tsp of ground white pepper
  • 2 tbsp of whole milk + more for adjusting
  • 2 tsp of lemon juice
  • 1 1/2 stick (170 grams) of unsalted butter, cubed

To set up a stand-mixer, check if the whisk-attachment on your machine, when lowered, is positioned super closely to the very bottom of the mixer-bowl.  This depends on the manufacture and for example like mine that is quite poorly made, leaves a small room between the very bottom of the mixer-bowl, which means it can’t sufficiently whisk ingredients that’s in a very small amount (which is what we’re doing).  If that’s the case with your mixer as well, place a folded kitchen-towel on the bottom of the mixer-bowl to elevate its position, twist and turn the bowl so it stays in place.  This will allow the whisk to touch the very bottom of the mixer-bowl and whisk efficiently.  You can use a hand-held mixer with a whisk attachment as well.

Place the egg yolks, salt and ground white pepper in the stand-mixer.  Heat 2 tbsp of whole milk in the microwave on high for 20 seconds, or until it starts to boil (best to use a clear glass for this so you can see).  Turn the mixer on high and slowly poor in the hot milk.  Once incorporated, keep mixing on high for 5 ~ 6 minutes until the mixture is thick and creamy, almost doubled in size.

Meanwhile, place the cubed unsalted butter in a pot that allows easy pouring (a stainless-steel milk pitcher works wonderfully).  If you don’t have such things, you can brown the butter in the pot and feed it to the mixer with a spoon.  Set the pot over medium-heat and cook.  The butter will melt, then starts to foam and bubble, which will then eventually subside in 5 ~ 6 minutes.  Once the sizzling and bubbling starts to die down, it mean the butter is starting to brown and specks of browned bits will start to settle on the bottom of the pot.  Watch closely and let butter brown even further then how you would normally do.  The butter will smell extremely nutty and fragrant.

The browned/burnt butter is now ready.  If your pot/milk pitcher doesn’t pour cleanly (that the liquid runs down on the side of the pot/pitcher), wrap a kitchen towel around it when you pour.  Mix 2 tsp of lemon juice into the egg yolk mixture, then with the mixer mixing on the highest speed, start drizzling the butter into the mixer-bowl.  SLOWLY, and I mean DROP BY DROP in the beginning.  You can increase the drizzling amount mid-way through, when a definite emulsification has established in the mixer, but stop drizzling for a few seconds if you see liquid butter still trying to work itself into the egg yolks.  The mixture will start to thicken up considerably.  It should take you no less than 6 ~ 7 minutes to incorporate all the butter.

If, God forbid… the sauce starts to break (you’ll see liquid butter separating from yolk-solids), mix in 1 tbsp of warm milk and it should supposedly come back together.

Once all the butter is incorporated, check the consistency of the sauce.  If it’s too thick to your liking, add more warm/hot milk to loosen.

To keep the sauce warm (and it HAS TO stay that way because once butter cools, it will solidify), bring a small pot of water to simmer then TURN OFF the heat completely.  Let the mixer-bowl sit on top of the pot, WITHOUT THE BOTTOM touching the hot water.  Give it a whisk once every few minutes.

You can also keep the hollandaise in the fridge, which it will then solidify.  To bring it back to life, heal 1 tbsp of whole milk over low heat until it starts to simmer.  Remove the pot away from heat and use a whisk to slowly incorporate the cold hollandaise, 1 ~ 2 tbsp at a time, into the milk.  Only apply more heat to the pot if the sauce refuses to melt, until all the hollandaise is whisked into the milk.  If the sauce breaks, take it off heat and add more COLD milk and whisk vigorously.  It should do the trick.

BONUS:  Onsen eggs for brunch


If you don’t want to poach eggs under pressure when you are hosting a brunch party, you can make these beautifully soft-poached onsen eggs the day before.  Keep them in the fridge and 10 minutes before serving, warm them up in hot water (NO HOTTER THAN 158F/70C).  An alternative, thermal water-bottle method here.

Fill a cast-iron pot (which retains heat better) with water (the amount of water MUST BE AT LEAST 4~5 times the volume of the number of eggs you’re cooking), and insert a heat-thermometer in the center of the pot.  Bring the temperature of the water to 167F / 75C, then turn the heat down to THE LOWEST your stove can manage (a whiff of flame only).  Carefully lower ROOM-TEMPERATUREeggs into the water, which is going to lower the temperature of the water to approximately 158F / 70C.  Now you MUST maintain the temperature of the water at 158F / 70C for the entire duration (fluctuation between a couple of degrees is acceptable).  If the temperature drops, turn up the flame ever-so-slightly, and if it increases, add some cold water to bring it down (you’ll get the hang of it quickly).  The SECOND you lower the eggs into the water, set the timer:

  • Medium-size eggs (50 ~ 57 grams) will need 20 ~ 21:30 minutes
  • Large-size eggs (57 ~ 64 grams) will need 21:30 ~ 22 minutes
  • Extra-large-size eggs (64 ~ 71 grams) will need 22 ~ 23 minutes

Once the timer goes off, immediately transfer all the eggs into COLD water until COMPLETELY COOLED DOWN.  You can refrigerate the eggs until needed, and bring it back to warm-temperature by submerging it in hot tap-water for a few minutes.


  • Belinda @themoonblushbaker

    November 12, 2013 at 8:39 PM Reply

    Seriously you have elevated the brunch classic new and unspeakable heights! that sauce is so golden and CREAMY. I WANT TO LICK THE SCREEN!! *sorry about the caps, but so excited!*

  • Sophie

    November 13, 2013 at 4:12 AM Reply

    BROWN BUTTER hollandaise! Wow, brilliant! I agree with you that blenders make a mockery of being able to collect anywhere near the amount of what one began with after it splatters through all the corners and crannies…. stand mixer, much-improved! This sounds so insanely good. We have a Brunch Club with our friends. I can’t wait to show this off.

    (Thanks for sticking it out on the experimentation for us!)

  • Rochelle @ Oh So Sweet Baker

    November 13, 2013 at 7:49 AM Reply

    Totally loving the colour of this hollandaise and the idea of the brown butter. This would be amazing over fish with capers and potatoes

  • Debra @ The Saffron Girl

    November 13, 2013 at 7:18 PM Reply

    I just love reading your posts! You make me smile each time. Thank you. And this looks and sounds DELICIOUS!!!! I’ve never made hollandaise with butter (only olive oil)… I’m going to have to give it a try.

  • Shanna

    November 13, 2013 at 8:41 PM Reply

    sounds totally delicious! YOU ROCK!!! :-)

    I am from Belgium (and live a 2 hour drive from Paris ;)) and we are not so afraid from hollandaise :-)). I always make mine directly on the stove with no problem at all.

    The trick is to whisk the egg yolks until pale BEFORE you put them on the stove and…. always add a teaspoon of water. This will help to stabilise the fat (egg yolks) on fat ( butter) because that’s the reason why it separates (1 egg can only absorb a certain amount of fat and mixture can not go higher then 83 degrees Celsius), if the sauce is ready mix a tablespoon of cream in. Just a last tip: if you want the sauce to be more ‘airy’ add one or two tablespoons of water in the beginning.

  • zap

    November 14, 2013 at 1:12 AM Reply

    I have made the blender Hollandaise many times and it’s dead easy. I just find that the Ripert version has too much butter for my taste.
    See here: http://zapxpxau.blogspot.com/2012/06/some-delayed-spring-photos.html
    Blender is like 1.5 litres while a stand mixer bowl is like 4 to 5 litres?
    The sandwich looks great :)

    • Mandy L.

      November 14, 2013 at 2:03 AM Reply

      Zap, good job with your blender hollandaise! I guess for me it isn’t about the volume but (maybe its just my blender) I feel like blender just splashes things everywhere, even only through the tiny hole in the middle of the lid. I literally had to wash the counter afterward…

  • ATasteOfMadness

    November 17, 2013 at 1:22 AM Reply

    Wow!! I can’t believe I have never made hollandaise before!! This looks fantastic!

  • Winnie

    November 17, 2013 at 8:21 PM Reply

    Great write-up! A stand mixer is definitely the way to go!

  • Zack

    January 12, 2015 at 6:32 PM Reply

    FYI You can adjust the depth of most stand mixer tools. Use a wrench to loosen the nut at the top of the tool, unscrew the tip a bit, and then tighten the nut again. Repeat until you get a depth you’re happy with.

    • mandy@ladyandpups

      January 12, 2015 at 6:36 PM Reply

      Zack: wow! Never heard of this tip! Gonna see if it works on my blender today…

  • ishitaboss5575

    July 16, 2021 at 6:41 AM Reply

    It is not everyone’s business to write such a great post, one person in a million can write such a beautiful post and you are one of those millions. I hope that you will write more beautiful posts in life and also hope that you will keep climbing the ladder of achievement in your life, very few people do this but I have full hope from you.

Post a Comment