EMERGENCY SKILLET COOKIE


25 responses to “EMERGENCY SKILLET COOKIE”

  1. Skillet cookies freak me out because…well..somebody’s got to eat them. And I can’t imagine being that somebody. But perhaps someday, in the depths of another arctic blast, knowing that my salary doesn’t justify keeping my house at 58 degrees F, and realizing that I could have gone a totally different career direction and actually be making money right now, I could bust one of these out. I guess I can pay to turn my oven on. I do hope things are okay over there!

  2. Last week I bought a 4-pack of tiny skillets with pre-made cookie mix at Costco because I thought the pans looked cool. I told myself that I would make some gambas alla plancha or something fancy, but truthfully I just wanted emergency skillet cookies. The cookie mix is garbage, but I thought it worked in a pinch. And now… this recipe. It just shames me. Those mini skillets are getting a workout tonight!

  3. I am so pleased to have discovered your site. You make me want to hunker down in the kitchen and make everything you show us. I am a dump and pour cook and so there fore not such a great baker as I’m not as precise or patient as is normally required..
    I made the skillet cookie and it was delicious but more cakey than your version turned out. I didn’t have the dark chocolate so used the semi and milk chocolate. Other than that I followed pretty exactly. Any idea as to what I could have done differently. I’m craving the gooey version… Or maybe I’ll just eat the dough ( mine did resemble batter more than dough if that provides a clue )
    Love to hear your thoughts if you have time.
    Regardless I adore your site!!
    Alex

    • Alex, hm…. I wondered if it was because the egg was over-whipped, hence created too much air bubbles in the dough, which made it expand too much? And every oven is different, so I think maybe your cookie was over-baked and therefore had a more “set” texture? Try to underbake it next time and see how it turned out!

  4. What a brilliant idea, a giant cookie! Will definitely be making this during this weekend… um, adapted of course to the ingredients I have here. Have a great weekend.

  5. Mine turned out ridiculously fluffy, yet ever so magical! I think the extra fluff came from my “All Purpose Self Rising” flour, but it didn’t affect the cookie taste! Perfect for an emergency!

  6. I made this last night to serve my adult kids for dessert after a dinner…they went at it like 8 year olds. Fortunately for me there is hardly anything left today. I do have a question though. I made it following the directions to the letter but my skillet cookie raised up instead of looking all dense and melty like in the photo…what did I do/not do?

    • Kari, my best guess is: 1). my cookie raised up quite a bit during baking as well, and then it “deflated” during a bit of cooling just like any other cookies. If yours didn’t deflate, it might be because it was overbaked a bit that the structure of the cookie is already “set”. I took my cookie out when the center was still quite “wobbly”, and it stayed quite soft even after a bit of cooling.

      2). Perhaps you used an extra-large egg and therefore too much egg-content in the dough made it rise? This is a very small batter as you can see, so little things can make quite a difference.

      I will try baking the cookie again and see if I get any additional input.

  7. I made the cookie, with all the recipe updates, and it, too, rose to cake height, albeit a thin cake. Still it was so utterly delicious, I didn’t care. Your blog is original and brilliant. Especially loved your valentine/marriage post. Married my first love, too, and 45 years later, it’s still the best. (Yes, we are old hippies.)

    • Susie, sorry but I’m not sure what went wrong there. Try reducing the baking soda to 1/8 tsp and see how it goes. When all else fails (And I do this sometimes when I over-baked it), poke a few holes on the baked cookie and press it down with a spoon. Yeah. it kinda works, too.

  8. Can I just tell you you’re an amazing writer? Also the cookie looks amazing, I love baking in skillets, something so nice and rustic about it. :)

  9. original and intelligent. my favorite company. thank you so far. theese and the espresso flan are top of my list.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

×